If you're going to bill your game as being true to the spirit of the original source material, one thing you really need to accept is the likelihood that the game is not going to be true to the spirit of some modern sensibilities. The developers of this Conan RPG don't appear to understand that.
We made changes to Conan the Wanderer on a cultural consultant’s recommendations that created a more rounded and well-developed representation of the fictional cultures based on their obviously real South and East Asian counterparts. Word choices were edited throughout for tone, like removing “exotic” and “mysterious” replacing it with a better adjective to describe its people and places, so that players inhabiting eastern characters in their games aren’t just a stereotype of strange, unknown people, and placed them at the center of this book. This was an issue for us in the original version, as it often assumed to paint all eastern characters with the same brush, instead of inspiring a sense of rich societies and cultures.
The material is and always has been wholly faithful to Robert E Howard. We’re not changing anything about the setting or the world. Not a single word of REH’s text has been altered. The only adjustments are being made to the game content itself, or fiction we’ve derived and extrapolated from his works, particularly the way we discuss and present that material.
I'm not saying there is anything intrinsically wrong with a culturally sensitive Conan, although that would arguably work much better as a parody than as a straight-faced RPG. But you can't honestly advertise the game as being Robert E. Howard's Conan.
What’s wrong with portraying people from a radically different civilisation as being somewhat unique and inherently strange to the local people.
ReplyDeleteIn the legend of the 5 rings RPG, the players play samurai in a fantasy themed around eastern Ideas, one of the group’s are seen as strange and barbaric because they rode off for a few hundred years and lived with the barbarian races of the west before returning.
It’s not racist, it’s aknowledging that some societies, cultures, and the people they create, are different from the norm that the game is centred around.
"PC Conan" has to be one of the dumbest things I've ever heard.
ReplyDeleteConan the Culturally Sensitive would be hilarious and I would definitely in on it. Take a leaf from the Hercules: The Legendary Journeys show and just dial it up to eleven. I would read/watch/play/whatever.
ReplyDeleteThere is nothing they wont geld
ReplyDelete